2193 Macadamia St, St. James City, Florida 33956

Discover one of Pine Island’s most exclusive waterfront lifestyles in the gated boating community of Pine Island Shores, where privacy, exceptional boating access, and relaxed island living come together in a setting unlike any other. Tucked away on a quiet private street, this custom-built waterfront retreat offers 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, a heated saltwater pool & spa, and quick, direct Gulf access from a deep-water canal designed for serious boaters. Whether you’re heading to Pine Island Sound for world-class fishing or island hopping to Sanibel, Cayo Costa, Boca Grande, and beyond, you’ll be on the water within minutes. Built with durable Hardie board siding & shutters throughout, the home blends coastal elegance with lasting quality and peace of mind. The seawall was replaced in 2023, while the composite dock features a 14, 000-pound boat lift, covered captain’s walk with hard-top roof, plus water & electric—everything needed for effortless days on the water. Indoor & outdoor living blend seamlessly with a screened balcony off the kitchen & great room, perfect for morning coffee or evening dinners overlooking the water, while the open front balcony offers front-row seats to spectacular Southwest Florida sunsets. Inside, the bright open-concept living area features a spacious kitchen with separate cooktop, vented hood, double wall ovens, stainless steel appliances & oversized walk-in pantry. Two guest bedrooms, full bath, laundry room & elevator complete the main living level. The entire upper floor is dedicated to a private primary retreat featuring a beautifully remodeled ensuite bath with walk-in shower, custom dual-sink vanity & spacious California-style walk-in closet. Downstairs, a rare four-car garage, generous storage & versatile bonus room with half bath provide ideal space for entertaining, hobbies, a home gym or poolside convenience. Pine Island Shores is prized for its peaceful atmosphere, beautifully maintained surroundings, and community standards that help preserve the neighborhood’s charm and waterfront character. Residents enjoy the peace of mind of a gated community, quiet streets ideal for walking & biking, limited short-term rentals that help foster a true residential community, and thoughtfully maintained standards that preserve the neighborhood’s beauty by minimizing trailer storage, excessive vehicle parking, and visual clutter. Despite its tranquil setting, the community offers convenient access to shopping, banking, dining, medical care, pharmacies, the post office & emergency services. More than just a waterfront home, this is an opportunity to own in one of Pine Island’s premier gated boating communities—a place where exceptional boating, privacy, pride of ownership, and an unmatched waterfront lifestyle come together in a setting that is truly rare.

Listing courtesy of Century 21 Selling Paradise.

Questions about this home? Contact Sal DiBenedetto · Explore Estero communities · What’s my home worth?