CHERRY ESTATES

Cherry Estates is a small canal neighborhood in St. James City, the community at the southern end of Pine Island in Lee County (ZIP 33956). It is an older, boat-oriented subdivision: most homes sit on saltwater canals with direct access to Pine Island Sound and the Gulf. Streets include Bounty Lane, Skipper Lane, Cherimoya Lane, Dewberry Lane and Blueberry Lane.
Homes and Prices
Lots are small, about 0.09 to 0.10 acre, and most homes are modest one-story houses of about 1,300 sq ft, many built in the 1980s, along with stilt homes and rebuilds. Asking prices ran from about $169,000 to $449,900, averaging about $287,000 (VIP Realty, Oct 2026). For example, a furnished 1987 canal-front two-bedroom with a dock, boat power, a metal roof and a seawall replaced in 2018 listed at $350,000 (MLS, 2026).
Amenities and Lifestyle
There is no clubhouse or pool; the amenity is the water. Owners keep boats at their own docks for fishing and island-hopping to Cabbage Key, Useppa and the barrier islands. Listings stress seawall age, dock condition and boat lifts, and these matter more here than interior finishes.
HOA and Fees

MLS listings show no association amenities and no HOA fee, and we found no official association.
Confirm any deed restrictions with a title search.
Check the flood zone, elevation certificate and wind-mitigation report, since these drive insurance costs for low-lying Pine Island homes.

Location
Stringfellow Road is Pine Island’s main road. It runs north from St. James City to Pine Island Center, where Pine Island Road heads east through Matlacha into Cape Coral. Plan on extra drive time to Fort Myers and RSW compared with mainland neighborhoods.
Use our map search to see current Pine Island listings or compare with Cape Coral homes for sale, and owners can review our Lee County flat fee listing. Call Sal DiBenedetto, Licensed Real Estate Broker, The DiBe Group, brokered by eXp Realty, at 239-256-5005.

94 Properties
Sort by: